Tafel.
← All insights

Testing policy

Test-optional does not mean test-blind. MIT brought testing back. Here's what the data shows.

MIT reinstated its SAT/ACT requirement after finding that scores, combined with other factors, improved its ability to identify students who would thrive. Many test-optional schools still admit mostly score-submitters.

Tafel takeaway

The submit-or-withhold decision should be data-driven, not ideological: at or above a school's 25th percentile, submit; below it, usually don't.

What the data shows

MIT publicly reinstated its testing requirement after concluding that scores help it identify students prepared to succeed there. Many schools that remain test-optional still publish class profiles where most admitted students submitted scores, with medians in high percentiles.

What families should do differently

Decide per school, against each school's published range for admitted students. If your child's score is at or above the 25th percentile, submit it. If it's below, generally withhold, but understand that test-optional schools may still, in practice, advantage score-submitters. Confirm each school's current policy.

How Tafel uses this

Tafel helps families make the submit-or-withhold call school by school against real ranges, instead of one blanket decision.

Sources

Sources are cited for educational analysis. Tafel is independent and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by the universities or research organizations referenced. Policies change, confirm specifics with the school.

Apply the research to one student

Turn broad admissions principles into a clearer next move.

The Tafel Admit Case Method helps families identify the strongest admit reason, highest-leverage gap, and right strategy stage for the student’s actual record.

Start strategy diagnosticSee the method